breme.

Troubleshooting · Associations and member organisations · Gmail and Outlook · Inbox

Why do our members keep asking the same questions by email when the answers are on our website?

By BREME · Updated

The short answer

When members keep asking the same questions, run a two-week tally of every repeat email first. Then check four causes in order: the answer is hard to find, it's out of date, it's missing from your welcome and renewal emails, or the question needs a person. Fix each with a clearer FAQ link, saved replies in Gmail or Outlook, answers built into routine emails, and AI drafted replies a staff member checks before sending.

Who this is for: Membership officers, operations managers and small secretariat teams at Australian associations, professional bodies, clubs and peak bodies whose shared inbox fills with the same member questions every week.

The quick test: which problem do you have?

For two weeks, every time a member emails a question, add one line to a shared sheet: the question in a few words, the date, and whether the answer already exists on your website. Don't change anything yet.

At the end, sort the list. Most associations find a handful of questions make up most of the pile: how do I log in, when is my renewal due, where is my CPD record, how do I update my details, what's included in my membership. The pattern tells you which of the causes below to start with.

If most repeat questions are already answered on the website, start with cause 1. If the website answer is wrong or old, start with cause 2. If the questions cluster around joining and renewal, start with cause 3. If they need a judgement call, it's cause 4.

Why members keep asking the same questions

It is rarely because members are lazy. Usually the answer exists but sits three clicks deep, under a heading only staff would use. Or the answer is right but arrives at the wrong moment: the member reads about CPD in a welcome pack in February and needs it in June.

Membership software vendors make the same point: answer questions before they are asked, in welcome emails and auto replies, and keep an FAQ members can find. Seen through the member's journey, each repeat email marks a moment where the member needed something and couldn't see it.

The causes in order, and the fix for each

  1. Cause 1: the answer is hard to find. Fix: put your top five questions at the top of one FAQ page, each written in the words members used in your tally, not internal terms. Link it from the member portal login page, your email signature and the contact page.
  2. Cause 1, continued: stop retyping the reply. In Gmail on a computer, open Settings, See all settings, then the Advanced tab, and Enable Templates, then Save Changes. Write the answer in a new message, select More options, Templates, Save draft as template, then Save as new template. Each saved reply should answer in two lines and link to the FAQ entry.
  3. If your team uses Outlook on the web or the new Outlook for Windows, open a new mail, go to the Message tab, select My Templates, then +Template, add a title and the text, and Save. Microsoft notes My Templates holds short plain text, needs a qualifying Microsoft 365 subscription, and may be hidden if your organisation has turned add-ins off.
  4. Cause 2: the answer is out of date. Fix: give every FAQ entry an owner and a review month. Check renewal dates, fees wording, event details and portal steps each time something changes, and update the saved reply at the same time so the two never disagree.
  5. Cause 3: the answer arrives at the wrong moment. Fix: add the matching answer to the email members get just before they need it. Login help goes in the welcome email, renewal questions go in the reminder before the due date, and CPD questions go in the mid-year check-in. Then add an auto reply to the shared inbox that lists the top five answers with links and says when a person will reply.
  6. Cause 4: the question needs a person. Fix: keep these for staff, but let AI draft the first version. In Gmail with an eligible Google Workspace plan, reply to the email and use Help me write, then refine it with Formalize, Friendly or Shorten. Google warns Gemini may suggest inaccurate information, so a staff member reads and corrects every draft before it is sent.
  7. Re-run the tally. After a month, repeat the two-week count and compare it with the first one. Move any new repeat question into the FAQ, a saved reply or the right routine email.

How to tell it's working

Compare the two tallies. The number of emails about your top five questions should drop, and the ones that still arrive should take one click to answer with a saved reply.

Also watch the time from a member's email to your first reply. When staff aren't retyping the same answers, the questions that genuinely need a person get answered sooner. Check both numbers again just before your next renewal period, when the inbox is busiest.

Copy and paste

Email auto reply

Shared inbox auto reply

On the shared membership inbox, all year

Thanks for getting in touch with [association name]. We've got your email and a member of our team will reply within [number] business days.

In the meantime, these answer the questions we're asked most:

1. Logging in or resetting your password: [link]
2. When your membership renews and how to pay: [link]
3. Finding your CPD record or certificate: [link]
4. Updating your contact or practice details: [link]
5. What's included in your membership: [link]

If one of these sorts it out, you don't need to do anything else. We'll still check in to make sure.

Kind regards,
[Team name]
Gmail template or Outlook My Templates

Saved reply: renewal date question

When a member asks when their membership is due

Hi [first name],

Thanks for checking. Your membership is due on [renewal date], and you can see it any time under [portal section] after logging in at [portal link].

We'll also send you a reminder [number] weeks before it's due, with a link to renew in a couple of clicks. Our renewal FAQ is here if you need it: [link].

Thanks for being a member.

[Your name]
[Association name]
Shared spreadsheet

Two-week repeat question tally

Two weeks now, then again one month after the fixes

Columns: Date | Question in a few words | Answer already on website? Y / N | Link to answer | Cause (1 hard to find, 2 out of date, 3 wrong moment, 4 needs a person) | Fix chosen | Done Y / N

Questions people also ask

Why do members keep asking the same questions?

Usually the answer is hard to find, out of date, sent at the wrong moment, or genuinely needs a person. A two-week tally of repeat emails shows which one you have.

How do I create a canned response in Gmail?

Gmail calls them templates. Turn them on under Settings, See all settings, Advanced, then save a draft with More options, Templates, Save draft as template. They work in Gmail on a computer only.

Can our whole team share Outlook templates?

Microsoft says it depends on the platform and setup. In a shared mailbox, templates may be visible only to you or to everyone with access, so test it with a colleague.

Should we use AI to answer member emails?

Use it to draft, not to send. Google warns Gemini may suggest inaccurate information, so a staff member should check every draft before it goes to a member.

Do members actually read FAQ pages?

More often when the answer is linked at the moment they need it: in the auto reply, the welcome email and the renewal reminder, not only on a page they have to find.

Sources

Related guides

More guides for associations and member organisations

More AI automation guides

All AI automation guides · See AI automation

Want this running on its own

We set up the follow-up, email and agent flows in the software you already use, written in your words and timed around your customer's journey, then hand them over working.