Comparison · Associations and member organisations · Google Analytics 4 · Reporting
Should our association ask new members how they heard about us, or use tracking links, to see which marketing works?
The short answer
Use both, because they answer different questions. Add one optional how did you hear about us drop-down to your join form, saved on each member record. Tag every link in your newsletters, social posts and partner emails with utm_source, utm_medium and utm_campaign, and read them in Google Analytics 4 under Acquisition, Traffic acquisition. Once a month, compare the two and report three numbers: new members, their top source, and joins per campaign.
Who this is for: Membership and marketing staff at Australian associations, professional bodies, clubs and peak bodies who spend on several channels (newsletters, social, events, partner emails) and can't say which one brought in new members.
What this looks like
Your association runs a LinkedIn post, a partner newsletter mention, a conference stand and a member get-a-member push in the same quarter. New members arrive, the board asks which activity worked, and the honest answer is a guess.
The cost is not just the report. Without a source, next year's budget goes to whatever felt busiest, and the channel that quietly brought in most members gets cut.
Why it happens
Most join journeys have more than one step. Someone hears about you from a colleague, looks you up weeks later, then joins from a newsletter link. Each tool sees only part of that path, and nobody decided ahead of time where the answer would be recorded.
Join forms are also kept short on purpose. Associations Now describes the rule of thumb as making the membership application as short as possible, with any extra question needing to be worthwhile. So the source question often never gets added at all.
How did you hear about us, tracking links, or both?
A how did you hear about us question captures what the member remembers: the colleague, the conference, the podcast. It is the only way to see word of mouth and offline activity. MemberClicks suggests an optional drop-down field on the join form so new members can tell you how they learned about you, and notes this is hard to collect later. Its weakness is memory: people tick the last thing they saw, or Other.
Tracking links (UTM tags) capture the click that brought someone to your join page. Google Analytics says to always include utm_source, utm_medium and utm_campaign, and shows the results in the Traffic acquisition report. Their weakness is that they see only online clicks, and a member who heard about you at an event and then typed in your web address shows up as direct.
Side by side: the question is free, covers offline and word of mouth, and is tied to the member record, but depends on memory. Tracking links are precise for online campaigns and need no effort from the member, but miss everything offline and need a consistent naming habit. For most associations the right answer is both, with the question as the main record and links to split up your online campaigns.
The steps to set up both
- Write your source list. Six to eight options in plain words: a colleague or friend, my employer, an event or conference, a search engine, LinkedIn or social media, our newsletter or email, a partner organisation, Other (please say). Keep Other so you learn new answers.
- Add the question to your join form as an optional drop-down, placed after the required fields. Make sure your membership system saves the answer on the member record, not just in the form email, so you can report on it later.
- Agree a naming rule for tracking links before you tag anything. Google Analytics notes parameter values are case sensitive, so use lowercase only, one source per platform (linkedin, partner-name, newsletter) and one medium per channel (social, email, referral).
- Tag every link that points to your join or renewal page. The pattern is your page, a question mark, then name and value pairs joined by an ampersand, for example yoursite.org.au/join/?utm_source=linkedin&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=autumn-join. Google strongly recommends also adding utm_id. Keep every tagged link in one shared sheet.
- Check the results in Google Analytics 4. Open Reports, Acquisition, Traffic acquisition and look at session source, medium and campaign. Anything you forgot to tag shows as (not set) or direct, which tells you where to tighten up next month.
- On the first business day of each month, export last month's new members with their how did you hear about us answer, and open the Traffic acquisition report for the same dates.
- Write the one-page report with three numbers: new members this month, the top two sources members named, and visits and joins from each tagged campaign. Add one line on what you'll do more of and one on what you'll stop.
How to tell it's working
After the first month, fewer than one in five answers should be Other or blank. If more are, your option list doesn't match how members actually find you, so read the Other answers and add the common ones.
After three months you should be able to name the channel that brings the most members, and see whether your tagged campaigns agree with what members say. When the two disagree, trust the member answer for offline and word of mouth, and the links for which online post did the work.
Copy and paste
Join form source question
Optional field, after the required details
How did you first hear about [association name]? (optional) - A colleague or friend - My employer or workplace - An event, conference or webinar - Searching online - LinkedIn or other social media - Our newsletter or an email from us - A partner organisation: [name] - Other (please tell us): [free text]
Tracking link naming sheet
Before any campaign link goes out
Columns: Date | Campaign name (lowercase, hyphens) | utm_source | utm_medium | utm_campaign | utm_id | Full tagged link | Where it was posted | Owner Example row: [date] | autumn-join | linkedin | social | autumn-join | aj01 | [your join page]?utm_source=linkedin&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=autumn-join&utm_id=aj01 | Company page post | [name]
One-page monthly marketing report
First business day of each month
Subject: Where our new members came from in [month] 1. New members: [number] (last month: [number]) 2. Top sources members named: [source 1] ([number]), [source 2] ([number]) 3. Tagged campaigns: [campaign]: [visits] visits, [joins] joins; [campaign]: [visits] visits, [joins] joins Doing more of: [one line] Stopping: [one line] [Your name]
Questions people also ask
Should 'how did you hear about us' be a required field?
Keep it optional. A short join form matters more, and an optional drop-down still gets plenty of answers because it takes one click.
What options should a how did you hear about us question have?
Six to eight plain-word options that match your real channels, plus Other with a text box. Review the Other answers monthly and add common ones.
Where do I see UTM results in GA4?
Google Analytics shows them in Reports, Acquisition, Traffic acquisition, using the session source, medium and campaign dimensions.
Why does most of our traffic show as direct?
Visits from links without tags and typed-in web addresses have no campaign details to report. Tagging every link you control shrinks the direct pile over time.
How do we track members who join at events?
Tracking links can't see them, which is why the join form question matters. You can also give events their own short link or QR code with tags.
Sources
- [GA4] URL builders: Collect campaign data with custom URLs, Google Analytics Help
- Membership forms: the questions to ask, MemberClicks
- Is your membership application asking the right questions?, Associations Now